Ontario Car Insurance Cancellation Fees: Complete Guide 2025
Everything you need to know about cancelling auto insurance in Ontario - fees, penalties, and how to save money
Quick Answer: Car Insurance Cancellation Costs in Ontario
Typical cancellation cost: 10-20% penalty on unused premium
Example: $1,200 annual premium, cancel after 3 months = ~$90-180 penalty + you keep only partial refund
Table of Contents
How Car Insurance Cancellation Fees Work in Ontario
When you cancel your car insurance policy in Ontario before its expiration date, you'll typically face a short rate cancellation penalty. This isn't a separate fee—it's a reduction in your refund.
The Two Types of Cancellation
Short Rate Cancellation
- • Customer-initiated cancellation
- • 10-20% penalty applied
- • Reduced refund amount
- • Most common type
Pro Rata Cancellation
- • No penalty applied
- • Full proportional refund
- • Qualifying events only
- • Less common
When Pro Rata (No Penalty) Applies
- ✓ Selling your vehicle (with proof of sale)
- ✓ Moving out of Ontario permanently
- ✓ Total loss of vehicle
- ✓ Death of primary insured
- ✓ Sometimes: switching within same insurance company
Ontario's 14-Day Cooling Off Period
Good news: Ontario law provides a 14-day "cooling off" period for new policies. Cancel within 14 days of purchasing a new policy and get a full refund with no penalties.
Ontario Car Insurance Companies: Cancellation Fee Comparison
| Insurance Company | Short Rate Penalty | Min. Retained | Admin Fee | Pro Rata Available? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TD Insurance | 10-15% | 14% | $0 | Switching within TD only |
| Intact Insurance | 10-20% | 15% | $0-50 | Special circumstances |
| Desjardins | 7.5-15% | 10% | $0 | Yes, for specific reasons |
| CAA Insurance | 10-15% | 15% | $0 | CAA members only |
| Aviva Canada | 10-17% | 15% | $0 | Limited circumstances |
| Economical | 10-15% | 12% | $0-25 | Case by case |
* Rates and policies subject to change. Contact your insurer for current terms.
How to Minimize or Avoid Cancellation Penalties
1. Time Your Cancellation Strategically
- • Cancel at renewal (no penalty)
- • Wait until closer to expiry date
- • Consider if penalty exceeds remaining premium
2. Negotiate with Your Insurer
- • Ask about waiving penalties for loyal customers
- • Explain hardship situations
- • Request supervisor review
3. Check for Qualifying Events
- • Provide proof of vehicle sale immediately
- • Document moves out of province
- • Submit total loss claims properly
4. Consider Alternatives
- • Reduce coverage instead of cancelling
- • Suspend coverage temporarily (if storing vehicle)
- • Transfer policy to new vehicle
Real Cancellation Cost Examples
Example 1: Cancel After 3 Months
Policy Details:
- • Annual premium: $1,800
- • Time active: 90 days
- • Short rate penalty: 33%
Calculation:
- • Premium earned: $594 (33%)
- • Refund: $1,206
- • Penalty cost: $151
Example 2: Cancel After 6 Months
Policy Details:
- • Annual premium: $1,200
- • Time active: 180 days
- • Short rate penalty: 63%
Calculation:
- • Premium earned: $756 (63%)
- • Refund: $444
- • Penalty cost: $156
How to Cancel Car Insurance in Ontario: Step by Step
- 1
Review Your Policy
Check cancellation terms and calculate potential penalties
- 2
Contact Your Insurer
Call or visit your broker/insurer to initiate cancellation
- 3
Submit Written Request
Most insurers require written cancellation notice
- 4
Return Documents
Send back pink slips and any policy documents
- 5
Receive Refund
Refund typically arrives within 2-4 weeks
Need a cancellation letter template? Get our free template →
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does it cost to cancel car insurance in Ontario?
Cancelling car insurance in Ontario typically costs 10-20% of your remaining premium as a short rate penalty. If you paid $1,200 annually and cancel after 3 months, you might pay a penalty of $90-180 on top of the premium for time used.
Can I cancel my car insurance anytime in Ontario?
Yes, you can cancel your car insurance anytime in Ontario. However, you'll likely face short rate penalties unless you qualify for pro-rata cancellation (selling your car, moving out of province, or switching within the same company).
Do all Ontario car insurers charge cancellation fees?
Most Ontario car insurers charge short rate penalties for early cancellation, but not separate cancellation fees. The penalty is built into the refund calculation. Some insurers like Intact may charge a small administrative fee ($0-50).
What happens if I don't pay the cancellation fee?
Since the "fee" is actually a reduction in your refund, there's nothing extra to pay. However, if you owe money (paid monthly and used more coverage than paid for), the insurer may send the debt to collections, affecting your credit score.
Can I avoid penalties by reducing coverage instead?
Yes, reducing coverage (like removing collision/comprehensive) doesn't trigger cancellation penalties. This can be a good option if you're storing a vehicle or trying to save money without fully cancelling.
Calculate Your Exact Cancellation Cost
Use our free calculator to see exactly how much you'll get back when cancelling your Ontario car insurance