Short Rate vs Pro RataCancellationUnderstanding the Key Differences
Learn which cancellation method applies to you and how it affects your insurance refund
Currently Supports
Click any company to view their rate table
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Short Rate | Pro Rata |
|---|---|---|
| Penalty Fee | Yes (10-20%) | No Penalty |
| Who Initiates | Customer | Insurer/Special Cases |
| Calculation Method | Uses penalty table | Simple proportion |
| Refund Amount | Lower | Higher |
| Common Scenarios |
|
|
Real-World Examples
Pro Rata Calculation
Short Rate Calculation
Short rate penalty for this example: $69.37(6.3% less refund)
That's $69.37 less than you'd receive with pro rata cancellation.
When Short Rate Applies
- You voluntarily cancel your policy
- Switching to a different insurance company
- No longer need the coverage
- Moving (but keeping the insured item)
When Pro Rata Applies
- Insurance company cancels your policy
- Vehicle sold or home sold (with proof)
- Total loss of insured property
- Death of the named insured
- Sometimes: switching within same company
💡 Tips to Minimize Cancellation Costs
Avoid Short Rate When Possible:
- • Wait until renewal to switch insurers
- • Provide proof of sale for vehicles/homes
- • Ask if switching within company qualifies for pro rata
- • Time cancellations strategically
If Short Rate is Unavoidable:
- • Cancel early in the policy term (penalty is lower)
- • Compare penalty cost vs remaining premiums
- • Negotiate with your insurer
- • Consider reducing coverage instead
Ready to Calculate Your Refund?
Use our free calculators to see exactly how much you'll get back
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between short rate and pro rata cancellation?
Short rate cancellation includes a penalty fee (typically 10-20%) for early termination, while pro rata cancellation provides a proportional refund with no penalty. Short rate is used for customer-initiated cancellations, while pro rata applies to insurer-initiated cancellations or qualifying events.
When do I get a pro rata refund instead of short rate?
Pro rata refunds typically apply when: the insurer cancels your policy, you sell your vehicle/property, you experience a total loss, the policyholder dies, or you're switching to another policy with the same insurer.
How much more expensive is short rate vs pro rata?
Short rate cancellations typically cost 10-20% more than pro rata. For example, cancelling a $1,200 annual policy after 6 months: pro rata refund = $600, short rate refund = $444 (a $156 penalty).
Can I negotiate to get pro rata instead of short rate?
Sometimes. While policies typically specify cancellation terms, you may negotiate pro rata treatment if: you're a long-term customer, experiencing financial hardship, switching within the same company, or have a valid qualifying reason.
Short Rate vs Pro Rata: Complete Guide
When cancelling your insurance policy, the method used to calculate your refund can significantly impact how much money you get back. Understanding the difference between short rate and pro rata cancellations could save you hundreds of dollars.
What is Pro Rata Cancellation?
Pro rata cancellation is the fairest method for policyholders. You only pay for the exact time your insurance was active, with no penalties. If you used 3 months of a 12-month policy, you get exactly 9 months refunded.
Pro Rata Benefits:
- No cancellation penalties
- Fair, proportional refund
- Simple calculation
- Maximum refund amount
What is Short Rate Cancellation?
Short rate cancellation includes a penalty fee when you cancel your policy before its expiration. This penalty compensates the insurance company for administrative costs and lost business. The penalty typically ranges from 10% to 20% of your refund.
Short Rate Drawbacks:
- 10-20% penalty on refunds
- Higher penalties for early cancellation
- Less money back than pro rata
- Varies by insurance company
When Each Method Applies
Pro Rata Cancellation Applies When:
- Selling your vehicle or home: Most insurers offer pro rata when the insured item no longer exists
- Insurance company cancels: If they cancel for underwriting reasons, you get pro rata
- Total loss: Vehicle write-offs or home destruction typically qualify
- Death of insured: Estates usually receive pro rata refunds
- Military deployment: Some insurers offer pro rata for service members
- Policy replacement: Switching to another policy with the same insurer
Short Rate Cancellation Applies When:
- Voluntary cancellation: You choose to cancel for any reason
- Found cheaper insurance: Switching to a competitor
- No longer need coverage: Storing a vehicle or leaving property vacant
- Financial reasons: Can't afford premiums (though some insurers waive penalties for hardship)
- Moving: Relocating and cancelling instead of transferring
Real-World Examples
Example Comparison:
$1,200 annual premium, cancelled after 3 months (90 days):
- Pro Rata Refund: $900 (exactly 9 months unused)
- Short Rate Refund: ~$750 (after 15-20% penalty)
- Difference: $150 less with short rate
How to Maximize Your Refund
- Check your eligibility: Review if you qualify for pro rata before accepting short rate
- Time it right: If possible, wait until renewal to avoid all penalties
- Document everything: Keep records of why you're cancelling (sale receipts, etc.)
- Negotiate: Some insurers will waive penalties for good customers
- Consider alternatives: Reducing coverage might be cheaper than cancelling
Special Circumstances
Financial Hardship
Many insurers will consider waiving short rate penalties if you're experiencing genuine financial hardship. You'll need to provide documentation and speak with a supervisor.
Errors and Omissions
If your policy was issued with errors or you were misled about coverage, you may qualify for pro rata cancellation even for voluntary cancellation.
Grace Periods
Some insurers offer a "free look" period (usually 10-30 days) where you can cancel with a full refund. Check your policy documents for this provision.
💡 Money-Saving Tip:
If you're switching insurers, time your new policy to start when your current one renews. This avoids all cancellation penalties and ensures continuous coverage. You can usually notify your current insurer up to 30 days before renewal that you won't be renewing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I negotiate a pro rata refund instead of short rate?
Sometimes. Long-term customers with good payment history may be able to negotiate, especially if switching to another product with the same company or experiencing hardship.
Do all insurance companies use the same short rate tables?
No. Each insurer has their own short rate table with different penalty percentages. Some are more generous than others, which is why our calculator includes company-specific tables.
What if I disagree with the cancellation method applied?
First, review your policy terms. If you believe you qualify for pro rata but received short rate, file a formal complaint with the insurer. If unresolved, contact your provincial insurance ombudsman.
Is the cancellation method the same for all types of insurance?
Generally yes, but there can be variations. Auto and home insurance typically follow the same rules, while life insurance and commercial policies may have different terms.